The WFR argued that the severe localized pain last night warrants an evacuation. The patient was reluctant to leave the trip and asked that they not use their marine radio to arrange an evacuation. He thought the episode was over and he was feeling better; however, he agreed to the group beginning to paddle back toward the nearest town, just in case.
They broke camp and started the paddle. Initially the patient felt fine, and paddled with strength, but after a few hours he began to feel ill and developed abdominal pain. As they paddled swells, the pain worsened with every bump of the kayak until he was obviously uncomfortable and vomited his breakfast, without blood. His friends said, "enough is enough" and used the radio to contact the Coast Guard. They paddled to a nearby fish hatchery where a helicopter picked up the patient.
This patient had a ruptured appendix. In hindsight the surgeon believed it ruptured in the severe pain episode the previous night. He developed a serious abdominal infection and had a long hospital stay. He has completely recovered.
The protocol would not have caught this appendix before it ruptured, but the evacuation would have been sooner if they had agreed to it on the beach. Human dynamics come to play in every decision, and the stoic endurance of the pain, while admirable, was in this case, unwise. The patient remarked that this experience, his first serious medical problem, has made him aware that he has a tendency to deny physical complaints. His friend, the WFR, was proud of his skills and mulled over whether he could have been more persuasive at the camp. Lessons for all.