NOLS: National Outdoor Leadership School Home

 

Fall 2005 Issue
    Cover Article
    Message from the Director
    40 Years in the Making
    Profiles
- Joan Chitiea
- Homer Luther
- Gene Tremblay
- David Jones
- Tracy Young
    Wild Side of Medicine
    The View From My Front Porch
    Tap Tapley Returns to Lander
    Just Another 30 Days?
    Wyoming Gov. Speaks at NOLS 40th
    The First WFR: The Start of the Pitkin Years
    NOLS Honors Idaho Land Manager
    NOLS Grad Leads in 101st Airborne
    Alumni Discuss Climate Change with U.S. Senators
Leader Archives
  Address Update Form

Donate to NOLS

Contact Us


Recluse Spider Bites
By Tod Schimelpfenig, WMI Curriculum Director


Several times a year, I’m sent pictures of what are identified as a series of recluse spider bites. The images begin relatively benign, with only a small wound, and then dramatically evolve into an ugly rotting lesion. They’re often accompanied by comments on how common, yet underappreciated, these dangerous spiders are.

Finding claims of recluse bites is easy. Finding documentation is difficult. The noted toxicologist Findley Russell, M.D. remarks that 8 out of 10 bites in one study were misdiagnosed.1   Sean Bush, M.D., an envenomation specialist at the Loma Linda University School of Medicine, and frequent lecturer for the Wilderness Medical Society, says that fewer than 100 recluse bites have been confirmed and documented in medical literature.

I’ve pursued the origin of these ugly images back through the e-mail trails.  No one has ever been able to verify a source.  Once I tracked them to a professional biologist, who embarrassingly admitted he might have forwarded an Internet myth.

Spider bites are a wonderful example of our tendency to react strongly and perhaps illogically to unknown or scary risks. Spiders, the lead characters in more than one horror flick, are symbols of venomous danger, of messy housekeeping or simple arachnophobia. They are easily, but perhaps incorrectly, blamed for wounds. This is an unfortunate character assassination. Few of the many spiders worldwide can actually injure people, and overall spiders are beneficial—like when they eat insects that infest our foods (flies), are vectors of disease (mosquitoes), or are just ugly and unwanted (cockroaches, earwigs).

The New England Journal of Medicine recently published an article that argues that brown recluse bites are rare, and rarely accompanied by the vivid wounds in Internet myth images.2  The first spider seen may be falsely accused of the deed, or misidentified, especially when it’s delivered to the emergency room as a squashed dark mess.

According to Rick Vetter of the Department of Entomology at the University of California-Riverside, brown recluse spiders are rarely confirmed in states where they are not resident (the central Midwest, Nebraska, south to Texas and eastward to southernmost Ohio and north-central Georgia).  Stories of brown recluse spiders outside areas where they are endemic are highly suspect.3

The hobo spider (Tegenari agrestis) allegedly causes a necrotic wound similar to that of the brown recluse spider, along with a characteristic persistent headache. But in its native European habitat, the hobo spider is not considered poisonous to humans.  Documented claims that hobo spider bites actually cause necrosis are also rare.

A venom detection test would help solve this question, but a reliable test is not available.

There are a number of folk remedies for spider bites, as well as web sites promising miracle cures.  In reality, nothing has proven much better for healing than time and good wound care.

Do people get bitten by brown recluse spiders and develop necrotic sores?  Yes, but it may be unlikely outside the spiders’ home range, and the bites are rare regardless. 

References:

1.   Russell FE, Gertsch WJ. For those who treat spider or suspected spider bites. Toxicon 1983;21:337-9.

2.   Swanson, D., and Vetter, R.  Bites of Brown Recluse Spiders and Suspected Necrotic Arachnidism. N Engl J Med 2005;352:700-7

3.   Vetter, Rick.  The Myth of the Brown Recluse.  Accessed August 5, 2005 at www.entomology.ucr.edu.

 


If you're not getting The Leader in the mail and you want to, click here.

 

Chat:
Chat with a real person.
Share:

Sign up for the NOLSie News
NOLS Top of Page
NOLS Home About Us Courses Apply Wilderness Medicine Institute NOLS Professional Training Alumni Store Donate NOLS Home Parents Press Room School Resources Photos NOLS.TV Events WRMC The NOLS Blog Introduction About Leadership History Mission & Values Profiles Partnerships Frequent Questions Find a Course School Locations Skills Leave No Trace Financial Aid Academic Credit NOLS Pro Home 1-3 Day Courses 7-30 Day Courses Risk Management Staff Clients Design Your Course Contact NOLS Pro NOLS Pro 1-3 Days 7-30 Days Risk Management Clients Contact Us NOLS Pro Design Your Course NOLS Pro Staff Overview Outcome-based Curriculum Faculty Overview Outcome-based Curriculum Faculty Case Studies Overview Administrative Training Staff Training Consulting Conference: WRMC How to Apply Apply Online Download an Application Admission Policies WMI Home About WMI Courses Schedule FAQ Photos & Movies Curriculum Updates Employment Sponsors WMI Home About WMI Admissions Courses Schedule Host a Course Resources Gallery Alumni Home Trips and Events The Leader Alumni Chapters Employment Staying in Touch Volunteer Photos & Videos Home NOLS Photos NOLS.TV The NOLS Podcast NOLS on Flickr Leave No Trace Overview Leave No Trace Principles Leave No Trace Master Educator Course Host a Course Contact Enroll Map of Events Dream Expedition Leadership Week Press Room Images for the Press Archives